| # | Artist | Title |
| 1 | Denver & the Mile High Orchestra | Jingle Bells |
| 2 | Barenaked Ladies | Green Christmas |
| 3 | Glee Cast | Jingle Bell Rock |
| 4 | Matt Wertz | Snow Globe |
| 5 | Trans-Siberian Orchestra | Beethoven |
| 6 | Frank Sinatra | Christmas Memories |
| 7 | Amy Grant | Mister Santa |
| 8 | Clay Aiken | The Christmas Waltz |
| 9 | Seth Macfarlane | Mele Kalikimaka |
| 10 | Trans-Siberian Orchestra | Mozart |
| 11 | Burl Ives | Holly Jolly Christmas |
| 12 | The American Patriots | God Bless the USA |
| 13 | Tony Bennett | My Favorite Things |
| 14 | Sugarland | Nuttin’ For Christmas |
| 15 | Straight No Chaser | To Christmas! |
| 16 | Trans-Siberian Orchestra | Christmas Eve/Sarajevo 12/24 |